My last post dealt with unoriginality and remakes, this one takes the cake – please don’t let this happen.
Ryan Murphy, the creator of the hit TV series “Glee” (of which Babs is a huge fan), is apparently in line to possibly direct a remake of “The Rocky Horror Picture Show”. He has dedicated an upcoming Glee episode to the cult musical.
Now I am an admirer of Mr. Murphy when it comes to his TV show incarnations (I am a fan of Nip/Tuck as well). So he is a good show runner/creator.
But he is not such a good director – especially when it comes to the movies.
His film adaptation of Augustine Burrough’s successful novel “Running With Scissors” was a travesty (how can you make Annette Bening act so bad?). “Eat Pray Love” ( another successful novel), although not a flop at the box office, was greeted by a lot of hostile reviews. I personally expected a real dog of a movie, but it wasn’t that bad – just instantly forgettable. He always attracts a cast that is worth checking out and his films have an appealing visual style. It is just his storytelling skills are nil. It is interesting that Baz Luhrmann is interested in directing an episode of Glee – like minds?
He is also slated to direct the film adaptation of Larry Kramer’s AIDs themed play “The Normal Heart” into a film – Mark Ruffalo in the lead role (good casting). The other Babs – Barbra Striesand wanted to direct and star in it many years ago, now I am wishing she had – just to keep Mr Murphy away.
Back to the Rocky Horror remake idea.
There are a lot of reasons to not remake this camp classic, but the only real reason for me is that there is no way in the world that the extraordinary performance of Tim Curry in the role of Franknfurter can ever be topped – and I mean ever! So just leave it alone.
Mind you the rumoured remake a few years back that was to be directed by Stephan (Priscilla) Elliott was much less desirable, thank god that is not on the drawing board (or should I say slab?) anymore.
By the way, Mr Murphy is also in line to direct the big screen adaptation of the huge hit musical “Wicked” ( he sure is popular), he can have this one – the stage show was so awful surely it can only approve?
A message to Mr Murphy – stick to one thing for a little while – your baby “Glee” is suffering this season, Babs ain’t happy bout that!